US Withdrawal from WHO: Scotland's Top Doctor Voices Concerns Over Global Disease Monitoring

2025-06-03
US Withdrawal from WHO: Scotland's Top Doctor Voices Concerns Over Global Disease Monitoring
The Independent

Scotland's Chief Medical Officer, Sir Gregor Smith, has expressed significant concern over the United States' decision to withdraw from the World Health Organization (WHO). His anxieties center on the potential impact this move will have on global disease surveillance and the ability to effectively respond to future health crises.

The US, under the Trump administration, formally announced its intention to leave the WHO in July 2020, citing concerns about the organization's handling of the COVID-19 pandemic and accusing it of being overly influenced by China. This decision marked a dramatic shift in international cooperation on health matters, leaving many global health experts worried about the long-term consequences.

Sir Gregor Smith emphasized the crucial role the WHO plays in tracking and identifying emerging infectious diseases worldwide. "The WHO provides a vital global framework for disease surveillance, and its loss will undoubtedly create gaps in our ability to detect and respond to outbreaks effectively," he stated. He highlighted the importance of international collaboration and data sharing in preventing the spread of diseases, and warned that the US withdrawal could undermine these efforts.

The WHO's surveillance networks rely on data collected from various countries, including the US. The absence of this data could hinder the organization's ability to accurately assess global health risks and provide timely warnings. Furthermore, the US withdrawal weakens the WHO's financial stability, as the US is historically one of its largest contributors.

Beyond disease surveillance, the WHO also provides technical assistance and guidance to countries on a wide range of health issues, including immunization programs, health system strengthening, and emergency preparedness. The US withdrawal could limit the organization's capacity to deliver these essential services, particularly in low-income countries.

While the Biden administration has signaled its intention to rejoin the WHO, the process is complex and may take time. In the meantime, concerns remain about the impact of the US absence on global health security. Experts are calling for increased collaboration among remaining member states to ensure the WHO can continue to fulfill its vital mission.

Sir Gregor Smith's concerns resonate with many healthcare professionals who recognize the importance of a strong and well-funded WHO in protecting global health. The US withdrawal serves as a stark reminder of the fragility of international cooperation and the need to prioritize collective action in the face of shared health threats.

The situation underscores the need for Scotland and other nations to strengthen their own public health infrastructure and to work collaboratively with international partners to address global health challenges.

Recommendations
Recommendations