Martha Stewart Weighs In: Are Meghan Markle and Gwyneth Paltrow *Really* Lifestyle Gurus?

2025-07-31
Martha Stewart Weighs In: Are Meghan Markle and Gwyneth Paltrow *Really* Lifestyle Gurus?
People

Martha Stewart, the undisputed queen of domesticity and a lifestyle icon in her own right, has finally shared her candid thoughts on two of the biggest names in the modern lifestyle space: Meghan Markle and Gwyneth Paltrow. In a recent interview, the seasoned businesswoman didn't shy away from offering her perspective on the Duchess of Sussex's and Gwyneth Paltrow's influence, sparking a lively debate online.

For years, both Markle and Paltrow have cultivated incredibly successful brands built around lifestyle content. Markle, through her Archewell Foundation and previous social media presence, has focused on philanthropic endeavors, family life, and a curated aesthetic. Paltrow, with her brand Goop, has built an empire on wellness, luxury, and often controversial advice.

Stewart, known for her meticulous attention to detail and traditional approach to cooking, gardening, and entertaining, offered a surprisingly nuanced critique. While acknowledging the reach and popularity of both women, she questioned the authenticity and practicality of some of their offerings. Specifically, she playfully teased Paltrow's Goop, referencing its sometimes extravagant and pricey products. “I think Gwyneth has a lot of… ideas,” Stewart said with a wry smile, hinting that some of Goop's suggestions might be a bit out of reach for the average consumer.

Regarding Markle, Stewart seemed more diplomatic, praising her for her charitable work and family-focused content. However, she also noted that Markle's lifestyle is inherently different, given her status as a former royal. “She’s a duchess,” Stewart pointed out. “It’s hard to compare her to someone like me.”

The comments have ignited a flurry of reactions across social media. Some applaud Stewart's honesty, seeing it as a refreshing dose of reality in a world saturated with curated online personas. Others defend Markle and Paltrow, arguing that their brands provide inspiration and aspirational goals, even if they aren't always attainable. Still others are simply enjoying the spectacle of these three powerhouse women weighing in on each other's work.

Ultimately, Stewart's remarks highlight the evolving landscape of the lifestyle influencer industry. As consumers become more discerning, they're increasingly seeking authenticity and practicality from the personalities they follow. Whether Markle and Paltrow adapt to this shift remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: Martha Stewart’s opinion carries significant weight in the world of home and lifestyle, and her perspective is prompting a much-needed conversation about what it truly means to be a lifestyle guru.

This isn’t the first time Stewart has been vocal about the influencer world. She's previously collaborated with some influencers, demonstrating a willingness to engage with the modern media landscape while maintaining her own distinct brand of classic elegance and genuine expertise.

Recommendations
Recommendations