FridayOL

Auckland Dentist's Conduct Under Scrutiny: Further Breaches Found by Health and Disability Commissioner

Auckland-based dentist, Bharath Subramani, is once again facing scrutiny after the Health and Disability Commissioner (HDC) concluded a new investigation revealing additional breaches of patient rights. This follows his previous deregistration and multiple prior investigations into his professional conduct. The latest findings highlight ongoing concerns regarding the standard of care provided by Dr. Subramani, impacting patient safety and well-being.

The most recent investigation stemmed from complaints outlining serious errors in treatment, including a particularly alarming incident where a crown was fitted onto the wrong tooth. While Dr. Subramani has since offered an apology, the HDC's report details a pattern of failings that extend beyond this single error. These breaches encompass issues of communication, informed consent, and overall patient management.

Key Findings of the HDC Investigation

• Misplaced Crown: The initial complaint regarding the incorrect placement of a crown remains a central point of concern, demonstrating a significant lapse in precision and attention to detail.
• Communication Deficiencies: The HDC found that Dr. Subramani's communication with patients was often inadequate, failing to clearly explain treatment options, potential risks, and anticipated outcomes. This impacted patients' ability to make informed decisions about their healthcare.
• Inadequate Informed Consent: There were instances where patients were not provided with sufficient information to provide truly informed consent for procedures, raising ethical and legal concerns.
• Poor Record Keeping: The investigation also highlighted deficiencies in Dr. Subramani's record-keeping practices, making it difficult to track treatment progress and ensure continuity of care.

Impact on Patients and the Dental Profession

The HDC's findings are a stark reminder of the importance of maintaining high standards of care within the dental profession. These breaches not only caused distress and potential harm to individual patients but also erode public trust in healthcare providers. The ongoing investigations and sanctions against Dr. Subramani serve as a cautionary tale for all practitioners.

What Happens Next?

While Dr. Subramani has been previously struck off the dental register, the HDC's report will likely inform further disciplinary action. The Dental Council will consider the findings and may impose additional penalties or restrictions on Dr. Subramani's ability to practice dentistry in the future. The HDC has also made recommendations for improvements to Dr. Subramani’s practice, should he ever be granted permission to practice again, focusing on communication skills, patient management, and adherence to professional standards.

This case underscores the HDC’s vital role in protecting the rights of patients and ensuring accountability within the healthcare system. It reinforces the need for continuous professional development and a commitment to providing safe, ethical, and patient-centered care.