Heartbreaking Decision: Terminally Ill Girl, 10, Denied Life-Extending Medication by Health Panel

2025-08-06
Heartbreaking Decision: Terminally Ill Girl, 10, Denied Life-Extending Medication by Health Panel
Daily Mail

A devastating decision has left a New Zealand family reeling after a health committee cruelly blocked their 10-year-old daughter, Charleigh Pollock, from accessing the only medication providing her with some relief and extending her life. Charleigh suffers from Batten disease, a rare and devastating genetic disorder that progressively impacts the brain and nervous system, ultimately leading to a terminal diagnosis.

Batten disease is incredibly rare, affecting only a handful of children in New Zealand. It robs children of their abilities, leading to vision loss, cognitive decline, seizures, and eventually, a loss of motor skills. There is no cure, and treatment options are limited. For Charleigh, a specific medication had been providing a crucial lifeline, easing some of her symptoms and allowing her to maintain a degree of comfort and independence.

However, the Northern District Health Board (NDHB) recently denied further funding for the medication, citing concerns about its cost and limited long-term benefits. This decision has been met with outrage and disbelief by Charleigh's family, who argue that the medication is providing tangible improvements to her quality of life and extending her time with loved ones. They've launched a desperate campaign to overturn the decision and secure ongoing access to the vital treatment.

“It’s absolutely heartbreaking,” said [Charleigh's mother/father - insert name if available, otherwise remove]. “This medication isn’t a cure, but it’s giving us precious extra time with our beautiful girl. It’s giving her moments of clarity, moments of joy. To deny her this, when it’s clearly helping, is just cruel.”

The NDHB maintains that their decision was made after careful consideration of all available evidence and in accordance with their funding guidelines. They state that the medication's cost is significant, and the long-term benefits are uncertain. However, Charleigh’s family insists that the NDHB is failing to consider the human cost of their decision and the profound impact it is having on Charleigh’s well-being.

This case highlights the difficult ethical dilemmas faced by healthcare providers when allocating limited resources. It also raises questions about the role of health committees in making decisions that directly impact the lives of vulnerable individuals and families. The Pollock family’s story is a stark reminder of the importance of compassion and individualized care within the healthcare system.

The family is now seeking support from the public and legal avenues to challenge the NDHB’s decision. Their plea is simple: allow Charleigh to continue receiving the medication that is giving her a chance to live each day to the fullest, despite her devastating illness. Updates on their campaign can be found [link to campaign/petition if available].

This situation underscores the urgent need for greater support and understanding for families affected by rare and debilitating diseases like Batten disease, and a more compassionate approach to healthcare funding decisions in New Zealand.

Recommendations
Recommendations