Air India Crash: Lingering Questions and Expert Theories on the Tragic Downfall

2025-07-18
Air India Crash: Lingering Questions and Expert Theories on the Tragic Downfall
The i Paper

The tragic Air India crash last month continues to haunt the nation, with lingering questions surrounding the cause. While initial reports pointed towards potential mechanical failure, a recent, deeply unsettling report has ignited speculation that the pilot may have intentionally cut off the fuel supply. This development has sent shockwaves through the aviation community and prompted intense scrutiny of the investigation.

The core of this renewed speculation stems from a chilling cockpit voice recording. While details remain tightly controlled, sources suggest the recording contains indications that the captain, the experienced pilot at the helm, was involved in cutting off the fuel. This revelation, if confirmed, would fundamentally alter the understanding of the disaster and introduce a disturbing element of human agency into the equation.

What We Know So Far: A Timeline of Events

The Air India Express flight 737, operating as a repatriation flight from Dubai to Kozhikode, overshot the runway during landing on August 7th, 2020. The aircraft, a Boeing 737-800, crashed into a ravine, resulting in devastating consequences: 19 people onboard lost their lives, and over 100 sustained injuries. Initial investigations focused on factors like pilot fatigue, weather conditions (heavy rain), and potential errors in approach procedures.

The Fuel Cut-Off Theory: A Deep Dive

The new report alleging deliberate fuel cut-off is based on analysis of the cockpit voice recorder (CVR). While the full transcript hasn't been released, snippets leaked to the press suggest a sequence of events where the fuel supply was abruptly terminated. Experts are divided on the motivation behind such an action, should it be proven true. Theories range from a potential mental health crisis experienced by the pilot to a more sinister, yet unconfirmed, scenario.

Expert Opinions and the Investigation's Progress

Aviation experts are cautiously approaching the fuel cut-off theory, emphasizing the need for a thorough and impartial investigation. “It’s crucial to remember that this is a preliminary finding, and further analysis is required to establish the facts conclusively,” stated Captain Rajesh Sharma, a former Air India pilot. “The CVR can be complex to interpret, and we need to consider all possible explanations before jumping to conclusions.”

The Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) is currently leading the investigation. They are meticulously analyzing the CVR, flight data recorder (FDR), wreckage, and witness testimonies. The AAIB is also conducting psychological evaluations of the crew involved, a standard procedure in major air accidents.

The Broader Implications: Safety and Mental Health

Regardless of the ultimate cause, the Air India crash has prompted renewed focus on aviation safety protocols and the mental health of pilots. Airlines are facing increased pressure to implement more robust mental health screening and support programs for their employees. The incident also underscores the importance of redundancy systems and failsafe mechanisms in aircraft design.

What's Next?

The AAIB investigation is expected to take several months to complete. The findings will be crucial in determining the definitive cause of the crash and in formulating recommendations to prevent similar tragedies in the future. For now, the Air India crash remains a stark reminder of the inherent risks associated with air travel and the vital importance of rigorous safety measures and a culture of transparency and accountability within the aviation industry. The families of the victims deserve answers, and the aviation community is committed to uncovering the truth behind this devastating event.

Recommendations
Recommendations