FridayOL

England secured a narrow victory against Andorra, but the performance raised serious questions about the team's tactical direction under manager Roy Hodgson. This detailed player ratings breakdown assesses each England star's contribution, revealing a largely underwhelming display where Cole Palmer's 4/10 scoreline perfectly encapsulates the muddled tactics on show.

The match itself was far from a convincing display. While the three points were secured, the performance lacked the fluidity and attacking prowess expected of an England side. Roy Keane's scathing assessment, accusing the players of looking 'bored,' resonated with many watching, and the individual player ratings reflect a lack of cohesion and clear tactical instruction.

Goalkeeping: Jordan Pickford - 6/10

Pickford had little to do throughout the match, comfortably dealing with Andorra's limited attacking threat. A solid, if uneventful, performance.

Defence: Kyle Walker - 7/10, John Stones - 6/10, Harry Maguire - 6/10, Luke Shaw - 6/10

Walker offered a consistent attacking outlet down the right flank. Stones and Maguire, while not spectacular, provided a reasonably stable defensive presence. Shaw, too, was largely untroubled, although his attacking contributions were limited.

Midfield: Declan Rice - 7/10, Jude Bellingham - 6/10

Rice anchored the midfield effectively, shielding the defence and providing a platform for attacks. Bellingham, while showing flashes of brilliance, struggled to impose himself on the game consistently.

Attack: Noni Madueke - 8/10, Cole Palmer - 4/10, Dominic Calvert-Lewin - 5/10

Madueke was undoubtedly the brightest spark in attack, showcasing pace, skill, and a willingness to take on defenders. Palmer, however, had a frustrating evening, struggling to find space and make an impact. Calvert-Lewin, leading the line, lacked sharpness and struggled to get into the game.

Tuchel's Tactical Muddle

The disjointed performance highlighted a lack of clear tactical identity. The team seemed to be searching for inspiration, and the constant changes in formation and personnel only served to confuse matters. Roy Keane's comments about the players looking 'bored' suggest a lack of engagement and understanding of the tactical plan.

Looking Ahead

England face tougher opposition in the coming weeks, and Hodgson will need to address these tactical issues urgently. A more defined system and clearer roles for each player are essential if England are to compete at the highest level. The Andorra match served as a stark reminder that there is still much work to be done.