Why Were Acting Legends Maggie Smith and Joan Plowright Missing from the BAFTA In Memoriam?
The BAFTA Film Awards are a celebration of cinematic excellence, and a poignant moment within the ceremony is always the 'In Memoriam' tribute, honouring those we’ve lost from the film and television industry. This year, however, a noticeable absence sparked considerable discussion online: the omission of acting icons Dame Maggie Smith and Dame Joan Plowright. Viewers expressed disappointment and even anger, labelling the absence a 'disgusting' oversight. But there's a perfectly valid, and rather touching, reason behind their exclusion.
The 'In Memoriam' segment typically features photographs of the deceased accompanied by a musical score. While the selection process is understandably complex, aiming to honour as many contributors as possible, there's a particular protocol regarding spouses who are still living. The BAFTA guidelines, and a long-standing tradition across many awards ceremonies, dictate that spouses who are still alive are not included in the 'In Memoriam'.
Dame Maggie Smith's husband, Sir Richard Harris, sadly passed away in 2014. Similarly, Dame Joan Plowright's husband, the legendary Sir Laurence Olivier, died in 1989. Because both women are still actively working and contributing to the arts – both are cherished figures in British theatre and film – BAFTA chose to honour the memory of their late husbands in a different, more personal way.
A BAFTA spokesperson clarified the situation, explaining that the decision was made out of respect for both Dame Maggie and Dame Joan. It's a gesture acknowledging their ongoing careers and the fact that they are not in need of remembrance in the same way as those who have passed away. Instead, their contributions are actively celebrated through their continued work.
This explanation didn’t entirely quell the initial wave of criticism, with some viewers arguing that the tradition felt outdated. However, many others appreciated the sensitivity of the decision and understood the reasoning behind it. The debate highlights the challenges of creating a tribute that is both comprehensive and respectful, particularly when dealing with such personal and emotional circumstances.
Ultimately, the absence of Dame Maggie Smith and Dame Joan Plowright wasn't a slight, but rather a demonstration of a unique and considerate approach to remembering those who have left us, while simultaneously acknowledging the enduring presence of those who continue to enrich the world of entertainment. The BAFTA ceremony, despite this momentary controversy, remained a moving tribute to the talent and dedication of countless individuals who have shaped the landscape of film and television.
The discussion surrounding this year’s ‘In Memoriam’ serves as a reminder of the delicate balance awards ceremonies must strike when commemorating the lives and legacies of those within the industry, and the importance of clear communication to avoid misunderstandings and ensure respect for all involved.