Nayakan: Why Kamal Haasan & Mani Ratnam's Classic Still Outshines Modern Crime Films
The recent release of Thug Life has sparked much debate, with many viewers expressing disappointment and criticizing its deviation from expectations. While the film generated considerable buzz, the reviews and audience reception haven't been favourable, leading some to question its artistic merit. However, amidst this discussion, a timeless classic deserves renewed attention: 1987's Nayakan, a cinematic masterpiece that continues to influence and inspire filmmakers today.
Nayakan, directed by the visionary Mani Ratnam and starring the incomparable Kamal Haasan, isn't just a film; it's a cultural phenomenon. It's a gritty, realistic portrayal of a man's descent into the underworld, exploring themes of family, loyalty, and the corrupting influence of power. The film draws heavily from the American crime classic Scarface, but transcends mere imitation, weaving in deeply rooted Indian cultural and social elements to create a uniquely compelling narrative.
What truly sets Nayakan apart is its masterful storytelling and Kamal Haasan’s breathtaking performance. He embodies the character of Velakkrishnan/Nayakan with an intensity and nuance rarely seen. His portrayal isn't of a cartoonish gangster, but a complex individual driven by circumstance and a desire to provide for his loved ones. The film doesn’t glorify violence; instead, it portrays the devastating consequences of a life lived outside the law.
Mani Ratnam's direction is equally impressive. He utilizes long takes, evocative cinematography, and a pulsating score by Ilaiyaraaja to create an atmosphere of palpable tension and emotional depth. The film’s visual style, particularly the use of slow-motion and close-ups, is groundbreaking for its time and continues to influence modern filmmaking.
The comparison to Thug Life isn’t about declaring one film inherently better than the other. Rather, it’s about highlighting the enduring power of Nayakan. While Thug Life may have aimed for a contemporary, stylized take on the gangster genre, it arguably lacked the depth, authenticity, and emotional resonance of its predecessor. Nayakan, on the other hand, remains a benchmark for crime films, demonstrating the importance of strong character development, compelling storytelling, and a nuanced exploration of complex themes.
Beyond its technical brilliance, Nayakan resonates with audiences because of its universal themes. The film speaks to the struggles of immigrants, the complexities of family relationships, and the human desire for a better life – themes that transcend cultural boundaries and continue to be relevant today. It's a film that stays with you long after the credits roll, prompting reflection on the choices we make and the price we pay for them.
So, while the debate surrounding Thug Life continues, let's not forget the legacy of Nayakan. It's a reminder that true cinematic greatness lies not in fleeting trends or superficial spectacle, but in timeless storytelling and profound human connection. It’s a film that deserves to be revisited and celebrated for generations to come.