FridayOL

NRL legend Andrew Johns has sent shockwaves through the rugby league world with a bold claim regarding Nathan Cleary's unexpected struggles in Game I of the State of Origin series. While Blues fans watched in disbelief as the usually dominant halfback faltered, Johns believes there's more to the story than meets the eye, suggesting a “conspiracy” is at play.

Cleary, widely considered the best halfback in the NRL, had a quiet night by his standards, struggling to control the game and making uncharacteristic errors. The New South Wales team ultimately lost to Queensland 38-10, and Cleary's performance was heavily scrutinized. While some attributed the lackluster showing to the pressure of the Origin arena, Johns’ assessment is far more intriguing.

Speaking on Nine's Sunday Footy Show, Johns didn’t mince words. “I just think something’s not right with him,” he stated. “His passing game, his kicking game… it's just not right. I’ve watched him for years, and it’s just not him.” He went on to suggest that the Penrith star might be carrying an undisclosed injury or facing some form of external pressure impacting his performance.

The former Newcastle Knights captain’s comments have ignited a firestorm of speculation. Many are questioning what “something” could be affecting Cleary. Is it a lingering injury he’s been concealing? Is it the intense media scrutiny surrounding his recent off-field incidents? Or is it something else entirely?

“I’m not saying he’s not trying, but something is affecting him,” Johns emphasized. “He’s not the Nathan Cleary we know. He looks hesitant, and he’s not dictating the game like he usually does.” He pointed to Cleary's missed kicks and rushed passes as evidence of a player out of sync.

This isn't the first time Johns has publicly questioned a player's performance. Known for his blunt and honest assessments, he has a reputation for calling it as he sees it, even if it's unpopular. However, the level of concern in his voice regarding Cleary’s situation has resonated deeply with fans.

The timing of Johns’ comments is crucial. With Game II of the Origin series just around the corner, all eyes will be on Cleary to see if he can rediscover his form. Blues coach Brad Fenech will be hoping that Johns’ theory is unfounded, and that Cleary can shake off whatever is hindering him and lead the team to victory. However, if Cleary continues to struggle, questions about his wellbeing and the potential impact on the series will only intensify.

The mystery surrounding Cleary’s performance has added another layer of intrigue to an already highly anticipated Origin series. Whether Johns' theory holds water or not, one thing is certain: the debate surrounding Nathan Cleary's form will continue until he returns to his best.