Elizabeth Taylor Believed Her First Oscar Was a 'Sympathy' Award After Near-Death Surgery Experience

2025-08-04
Elizabeth Taylor Believed Her First Oscar Was a 'Sympathy' Award After Near-Death Surgery Experience
The Independent

Hollywood icon Elizabeth Taylor, celebrated for her beauty, talent, and captivating screen presence, harbored a surprising sentiment about her first Academy Award. The legendary actress, who tragically endured multiple brushes with death, confessed she believed her 1961 Best Actress Oscar for 'Butterfield 8' was largely a result of 'sympathy' following a harrowing surgery where she reportedly 'died four times.'

Taylor’s candid revelation, often recounted in biographies and interviews, sheds light on the complexities of fame and the sometimes-unpredictable nature of awards. 'Butterfield 8,' a film often criticized for its melodramatic plot and questionable acting, unexpectedly earned Taylor her first Oscar. While the film garnered mixed reviews, Taylor’s performance, portraying Gloria Wandrous, a former showgirl struggling with alcoholism and a complicated relationship, resonated with audiences and critics alike.

However, the timing of the award was particularly poignant. Just months before the ceremony, Taylor had undergone a life-threatening surgery to remove a dangerous kidney tumor. The procedure was fraught with complications, and according to accounts, the actress flatlined multiple times during the operation. The ordeal left her weakened and vulnerable, leading to widespread concern for her well-being within the Hollywood community and beyond.

Speaking about the Oscar win years later, Taylor reportedly remarked, “I felt as though I’d died four times during the operation, and then they gave me an Oscar. It was a sympathy vote, I’m sure.” This statement wasn't intended as a dismissal of the award itself, but rather as a reflection on the circumstances surrounding it. She acknowledged the incredible honor but also recognized the potential influence of public sympathy following her near-death experience.

Despite her initial reservations, Taylor went on to amass an impressive collection of accolades throughout her illustrious career, including a second Best Actress Oscar for 'Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?' in 1966. Her talent and enduring influence on the world of cinema are undeniable, and her story serves as a reminder of the challenges and triumphs that define a life lived in the spotlight.

The story of Elizabeth Taylor and her first Oscar is a fascinating glimpse into the life of a Hollywood legend – a woman who faced adversity with grace, navigated the complexities of fame, and left an indelible mark on the entertainment industry. It’s a testament to her resilience and the enduring power of her talent, even in the face of personal tragedy and public perception.

Further Reading: Explore Elizabeth Taylor’s biography for more insights into her life and career. Consider researching 'Butterfield 8' to understand the context of her first Oscar win and the critical reception of the film.

Recommendations
Recommendations