Steven May Faces Stiff Penalty After Controversial Incident with Carlton's Francis Evans

2025-07-23
Steven May Faces Stiff Penalty After Controversial Incident with Carlton's Francis Evans
Couriermail

Steven May's Actions Result in Significant Suspension Following Tribunal Hearing

Melbourne defender Steven May is facing a substantial suspension after appearing before the AFL Tribunal today to address the incident involving Carlton's Francis Evans. The contentious act, which occurred during the match, left Evans with a broken nose and a displaced tooth, sparking widespread debate and scrutiny within the AFL community.

The Match Review Officer initially graded the incident, prompting May’s mandatory appearance at the Tribunal. The focus of the hearing centred around the severity of the contact and whether May's actions were reckless or intentional. The Tribunal considered video evidence, witness statements, and arguments from both the AFL and May's legal representation.

The Incident and Its Immediate Aftermath

The incident itself involved May and Evans contesting a marking contest. Footage clearly showed May’s elbow connecting with Evans' face, resulting in the immediate injury. Evans was visibly distressed and required medical attention on the field before being escorted from the game. The severity of the injury, a broken nose and a displaced tooth, immediately raised concerns about the potential for significant disciplinary action.

Tribunal Deliberations and the Verdict

The Tribunal panel faced a complex task in assessing the incident. They needed to determine whether May acted recklessly, carelessly, or intentionally. Arguments presented focused on May’s awareness of Evans’ proximity and the potential for harm. May’s defence centered on the high-pressure nature of the game and the unintentional nature of the contact. However, the Tribunal ultimately found the incident worthy of a significant penalty.

What's Next for Steven May and Melbourne?

The suspension handed down by the Tribunal will have a significant impact on Melbourne's campaign. May is a key pillar of their defence, and his absence will be keenly felt. The club will need to adjust their strategy and rely on other players to fill the void. Furthermore, the incident serves as a reminder of the importance of player safety and the ongoing responsibility of players to maintain control and avoid unnecessary contact.

The AFL continues to emphasise player welfare, and incidents like this underscore the need for careful scrutiny and appropriate sanctions. The league’s commitment to protecting players is paramount, and the Tribunal’s decision reflects that commitment. The coming weeks will be crucial for Melbourne as they navigate this challenging period, and for Steven May as he faces the consequences of his actions.

The full length of May’s suspension is yet to be officially announced, but sources suggest it will be a substantial period, potentially sidelining him for several games. The AFL community awaits the official announcement with keen interest, as it will set a precedent for similar incidents in the future.

Recommendations
Recommendations