Auckland Dentist's Repeated Errors Lead to Further Health and Disability Commission Investigation

2025-06-30
Auckland Dentist's Repeated Errors Lead to Further Health and Disability Commission Investigation
RNZ

Auckland Dentist Faces Scrutiny After Multiple Breaches of Patient Rights

Auckland dentist Bharath Subramani, already facing professional repercussions, is once again under investigation by the Health and Disability Commissioner (HDC). This latest investigation has uncovered further breaches of patient rights, adding to a concerning pattern of errors and inadequate care. The dentist, who has previously been subject to several investigations and was recently struck off the register, continues to face serious allegations.

The Latest Incident: A Crown on the Wrong Tooth

The most recent case involved a patient receiving a crown on the incorrect tooth - a significant and deeply distressing error. While the dentist has since apologised for this mistake, the HDC’s investigation has highlighted a series of systemic failures in his practice. The apology, while acknowledged, does little to address the broader concerns about the quality of care provided to patients under his supervision.

HDC Findings: A Pattern of Negligence

The Health and Disability Commissioner’s report details a concerning pattern of negligence and a failure to adhere to accepted standards of dental practice. Beyond the incorrect crown placement, the investigation revealed shortcomings in record-keeping, communication with patients, and overall clinical judgment. These issues raise serious questions about the dentist's competence and commitment to patient safety. The HDC has emphasized the need for robust quality control measures within dental practices to prevent similar incidents from occurring.

Previous Investigations and Striking Off

This latest investigation follows a series of previous inquiries into Dr. Subramani’s practice. Previous findings led to significant concerns and ultimately contributed to his being struck off the dental register. The repeated instances of breaches underscore a deep-seated problem and highlight the importance of regulatory oversight in protecting vulnerable patients. The ongoing investigations demonstrate the HDC's commitment to ensuring healthcare providers are held accountable for their actions.

Impact on Patients and Future Implications

The cases involving Dr. Subramani serve as a stark reminder of the potential consequences of inadequate dental care. Patients deserve to receive safe and competent treatment, and failures in this area can have lasting physical and emotional impacts. This situation continues to fuel discussions around the effectiveness of current regulatory processes and the need for enhanced safeguards to prevent similar situations from arising in the future. The HDC is urging dental professionals to prioritize patient safety and adhere to the highest standards of care.

What happens next?

While already struck off, the HDC’s findings will likely inform future regulatory decisions and contribute to ongoing discussions about professional accountability within the healthcare sector. Patients who believe they may have been affected by Dr. Subramani’s care are encouraged to seek advice from the HDC and relevant legal professionals.

Recommendations
Recommendations